Custom Cookie Sets
Coordinated decorated sugar cookies built around your event theme, colors, names, dates, or favorite details.
Custom decorated sugar cookies · Hudson Valley, NY
Cookies made just for you.
Custom decorated sugar cookies designed to make birthdays, showers, weddings, holidays, and everyday celebrations a little sweeter.
Local pickup only · Shipping is not available
Sweet One · First Birthday
Made by hand
A little something sweet, crafted just for you.
Crafted by Megan is a small-batch home bakery specializing in custom decorated sugar cookies. Every set is planned around your colors, theme, and celebration so your cookies feel personal—not pulled from a template.
Whether you need a dozen cookies for an intimate celebration or a larger order for a party, I’ll work with you to create a cohesive set that looks beautiful on the dessert table and tastes just as good.
What I make
Custom cookies for every kind of celebration.
Custom decorated cookies start at $3 per cookie, with a minimum order of 1 dozen cookies. Each order is individually designed, and final pricing depends on cookie size, design complexity, color palette, and personalization.
Milestones & Parties
First birthdays, showers, baptisms, graduations, engagements, weddings, anniversaries, holidays, and more.
Large Event Orders
Need several dozen? Larger orders can be planned as a simplified, cohesive collection to keep them beautiful and party-ready.
Pricing
Message for pricing · 1 dozen minimum
Pickup
Hudson Valley, New York
Shipping
Not available at this time
Recent work
A peek at the cookie table.
Recent custom sets, from first birthdays and baptisms to outdoor adventures. Each collection is designed around the colors and details of the celebration.
How it works
From your idea to a boxed-up cookie set.
- 01
Tell me about your event
Share the date, quantity, theme, colors, inspiration, and any personalization you’d like.
- 02
Receive your quote
I’ll review your request and confirm availability, design direction, pickup details, and pricing.
- 03
I get crafting
Your cookies are baked, decorated, packaged, and prepared for pickup close to your celebration date.
Good to know
Frequently asked questions.
How far in advance should I order?
Earlier is always better, especially during busy holiday and event seasons. Send an inquiry as soon as you know your date and I’ll confirm availability.
Do you ship?
No. Crafted by Megan currently accepts local pickup orders only and does not ship cookies.
Can you copy a cookie design I found online?
Inspiration photos are welcome. I’ll use them to understand the style you like while creating a set that feels custom to your event.
Can you match my invitation or party colors?
Yes. Invitations, mood boards, décor photos, napkins, florals, and color references are all helpful when building your cookie palette.
How is pricing determined?
Each order is custom, so pricing varies based on your design, quantity, and the details needed to bring your cookies to life. Message me for a personalized quote!
Let’s make something sweet
Tell me what you’re celebrating.
Ready to place an order? Send an inquiry below, email me at orders.craftedbymegan@gmail.com, or DM me on Instagram @craftedbymegan_.
Please note: orders are local pickup only. Shipping is not available.